The Difference Between Religion and Intimacy with God
I am the vine; you are the branches. Whoever abides in me and I in him, he it is that bears much fruit. | John 15:5
5/19/2026
The Difference Between Religion and Intimacy with God
I am the vine; you are the branches. Whoever abides in me and I in him, he it is that bears much fruit. | John 15:5
Before my encounter with God in college, I was already a Christian. I was born into a Christian home, Catholic specifically. Without any prompting, I attended church services and every event the church offered, week after week. I went through every motion. And I felt nothing.
I wish I could say things improved immediately after God met me in that dorm room. But that would not be honest. Years later I found myself deeply involved in church, serving in multiple departments, showing up wherever help was needed, following every rule, and still feeling hollow on the inside. Something was present in my schedule that was absent from my soul. I knew something was missing. I just did not know what to call it.
What I eventually learned was the difference between religion and intimacy. And that difference is not small.
Religion Looks Like a Fish With a Calendar
A fish does not convince itself to need water. It does not schedule time with water. It cannot survive without water because water is the environment it was made for. That is how God designed us in relation to Him. We were not made to manage our relationship with Him through appointments and attendance records. We were made to be unable to live fully without Him.
Religion is a fish scheduling time to spend in the water. It is all the right activity without the right environment. And contrary to the fish who would die quickly without water, we do not always notice the slow death of a life lived in performance rather than genuine intimacy. We can look completely fine on the outside. That is what makes it so dangerous.
Jesus said it plainly in John 15:5. He is the vine. We are the branches. Apart from Him we can do nothing. Not less. Not less effectively. Nothing. This is not a scheduling instruction. It is a description of reality.
What Religion Looks Like, and What Intimacy Looks Like
Religion involves showing up without true engagement, wanting what God gives rather than who He is, carrying information without experiencing transformation, and maintaining the appearance of faithfulness without the connection that faithfulness is supposed to reflect.
Intimacy looks entirely different. It is knowing His character, not just His name. Recognizing His voice when it speaks. Being known by Him and not just knowing about Him. Bringing what is actually happening to the relationship, the doubt, the grief, the questions, the anger, instead of a rehearsed version of what prayer is supposed to sound like.
What the Clinical World Calls This
In clinical work, we distinguish between transactional relationships and transformative ones. A transactional relationship meets functional needs. It operates on an exchange. You give something, you receive something. It is useful but it does not change who you are at the level of identity. A transformative relationship, one built on genuine knowing and being known, produces change that goes all the way to the root.
What Jesus describes in John 15 is not a transactional arrangement. It is the most transformative relationship available to a human being. That is why religion, no matter how consistently practiced, can never produce what intimacy with God produces. The mechanism is fundamentally different.
What This Looks Like in Practice
A few years ago I was deeply wounded in a way I had not anticipated. I sat alone and did the only thing I knew would help. I started talking to God. Not with a prepared prayer. Not with the right vocabulary. Just describing where it hurt and how much. In bringing that pain to Him honestly, something in me began to open. The conversation led me to see the root of the wound more clearly than I had been able to on my own.
You cannot heal what you have not named properly. And you cannot name something properly if you are only bringing a polished version of yourself to the conversation.
That is what intimacy makes possible. The real version of you meeting the real presence of God. That is where healing begins.
Where to Begin
An honest, unscripted conversation is the best place to start. Not a performance. Not the words you think you are supposed to say. Just what is actually true for you right now.
From there, reading the Word with genuine curiosity, asking questions, sitting with what you read, builds your understanding of who He is. Prayer and worship deepen the connection. Community that takes God seriously creates the context where what you are learning can be lived out.
Moving from religion to intimacy is not a single decision. It is a daily practice of choosing depth over appearance, connection over performance, the Person over the program.
Subscribe for more devotional content at josianesomo.com so you do not miss what comes next.
Download the free God and Recovery Volume 1 (here) https://selar.com/0r24m1754f for a guided companion on this road from performance to genuine encounter.
If your church or community is ready to go deeper on this conversation, visit the Speaking page to explore having Josiane come to your space.